Motor Integration

Direct Drive, General

PROSCONS
  • Lighter → no power transmission system needed
  • More compact, allows for a larger chassis
  • More reliable → if one motor fails, only that wheel is compromised rather than a whole left/right side of the drivetrain
  • More points of failure by controlling each wheel independently
  • Longer wires, require protection

Integrated in the wheels

Anveshak 2020Nova 2019MANIPAL 2020

PROSCONS
    • Motors are protected from damage while traversing obstacles
    • Requires custom hubs to mount the motors to
      • Either have to tear apart COTS wheels or design completely custom wheels
        • Probably easier to design custom wheels 

External to wheels

ITU Rover 2020

Can still contain the actuator outside of the wheels and protect them within some housing

PROSCONS
  • Not constraining the wheel width to be wide enough to fit the motor and gearbox
  • Easy to implement on COTS wheels → no requirement for custom wheels or hubs, maybe a custom interface plate
  • Less compact design



Chain Drive, General


PROSCONS
  • Easy to install/remove and repair
  • Sprockets come in small diameters
  • Reliable, does not slip
  • High maintenance → requires tensioning, cleaning, and lubrication
  • Heavy

Belt Drive, General

PROSCONS
  • Low maintenance → once installed, shouldn't need tensioning, no lubrication required
  • Light
  • Precise machining required to position the belts properly so that they don't loosen over time
  • Harder to install and uninstall → require accessible openings that's the entire length of the belt
  • Typically rely on pulleys that are larger in diameter to sprockets
  • Fixed lengths of belt
  • More likely to slip when carrying heavy loads and due to vibration, thus reducing its efficiency

Wheel Motors in a Combined Gearbox

PROS

CONS
    • Can use as many/as few motors as desired
    • Motors and gearing all contained in one area that can be located away from potential harm
    • Not useable for all drivetrain styles
    • Bulky
    • If one motor fails, compromises the performance of all wheels connected to that gearbox

Wheel Motors Isolated, Not Directly Mounted

On this drivetrain, the chain runs through the boxtube for each wheel and uses 3D printed covers to protect the access holes to the wheel sprockets

PROS

CONS
  • Can position the actuators away from potential harm
  • Easy to mount the actuators
  • Long wiring + power transmission required = many points of failure
    • To protect would require additional casing/structures, which is more weight