Direct Drive, General
PROS | CONS |
- Lighter → no power transmission system needed
- More compact, allows for a larger chassis
- More reliable → if one motor fails, only that wheel is compromised rather than a whole left/right side of the drivetrain
| - More points of failure by controlling each wheel independently
- Longer wires, require protection
|
Integrated in the wheels
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/50352/503526324fb23d3acb66a572c2b4f90d8e3456f1" alt="Anveshak 2020 Anveshak 2020"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0fe87/0fe874dc4ef1a19a13738b9d19541445b74697c8" alt="Nova 2019 Nova 2019"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/359a0/359a0d91105134e5b1c5cf0c6c72e5ce1e5c6a35" alt="MANIPAL 2020 MANIPAL 2020"
PROS | CONS |
- Motors are protected from damage while traversing obstacles
| - Requires custom hubs to mount the motors to
- Either have to tear apart COTS wheels or design completely custom wheels
- Probably easier to design custom wheels
|
External to wheels
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/70ad0/70ad08485b38036b0e51ab2270bf86e2e92d3583" alt="ITU Rover 2020 ITU Rover 2020"
Can still contain the actuator outside of the wheels and protect them within some housing
PROS | CONS |
- Not constraining the wheel width to be wide enough to fit the motor and gearbox
- Easy to implement on COTS wheels → no requirement for custom wheels or hubs, maybe a custom interface plate
| |
Chain Drive, General
PROS | CONS |
- Easy to install/remove and repair
- Sprockets come in small diameters
- Reliable, does not slip
| - High maintenance → requires tensioning, cleaning, and lubrication
- Heavy
|
Belt Drive, General
PROS | CONS |
- Low maintenance → once installed, shouldn't need tensioning, no lubrication required
- Light
| - Precise machining required to position the belts properly so that they don't loosen over time
- Harder to install and uninstall → require accessible openings that's the entire length of the belt
- Typically rely on pulleys that are larger in diameter to sprockets
- Fixed lengths of belt
- More likely to slip when carrying heavy loads and due to vibration, thus reducing its efficiency
|
Wheel Motors in a Combined Gearbox
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5a1ca/5a1ca5e5094152c66e6b46f8c9a0d3d06e223324" alt=""
PROS | CONS |
- Can use as many/as few motors as desired
- Motors and gearing all contained in one area that can be located away from potential harm
| - Not useable for all drivetrain styles
- Bulky
- If one motor fails, compromises the performance of all wheels connected to that gearbox
|
Wheel Motors Isolated, Not Directly Mounted
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b00cf/b00cf678c1bca65231aeeb4567d78e0617c26288" alt=""
On this drivetrain, the chain runs through the boxtube for each wheel and uses 3D printed covers to protect the access holes to the wheel sprockets
PROS | CONS |
- Can position the actuators away from potential harm
- Easy to mount the actuators
| - Long wiring + power transmission required = many points of failure
- To protect would require additional casing/structures, which is more weight
|