Video Conferencing for Graduate Student Defenses
- Charlee Paige Van De Peer
- Trevor Bain
- Megan Winterburn
Health Computing can provide technical support when a graduate student proposal, comprehensive exam or thesis defence has online attendees. We recommend that Faculty and students participating in these defences review the following information to prepare appropriately.
On this page, we will refer to proposals, comprehensive exams and thesis defences as "defence".
Summary of responsibilities
Tips for a successful defence
Summary of responsibilities
Supervisor
Schedule the online component of the defence by sending a meeting invitation to the candidate and any committee members who will be attending online. For PhD Final defences (including hosting the online component), contact the Faculty of Health Graduate Studies Administrator for details on obtaining additional support and coordination from Health Computing
Zoom is recommended over Teams when non-UW attendees are joining online. However, supervisors should use the video conferencing platform they are most comfortable with. See Self-host a remote defence.
If Teams is chosen as the meeting platform, call-in details will be available only if a faculty member or staff member schedules the defense (i.e., don't have the student schedule it).
Health Computing can do a technology check 7-10 days prior to the defence by emailing hlthco@uwaterloo.ca and providing details regarding the defence date, time (and location if hybrid).
Contact Health Computing (well in advance of the defence date) if you have difficulties setting up the online meeting (hlthco@uwaterloo.ca)
Perform the role of host for the meeting
If issues arise during the defence, email hlthcomputing@uwaterloo.ca and include the meeting link and on-campus location
Health Computing IT specialist
Upon request:
conduct test video conference session with candidate and online attendees prior to the defence.
assist with in-room video conferencing equipment set up
provide technical support/troubleshooting during the defence
Candidate and Remote Attendees
Familiarize yourself with the online platform if you have not used it before.
Confirm attendance for test video conference session with Health Computing IT specialist.
Ensure you have all the equipment you need prior to joining the test and defence meetings.
Ensure your device and internet connection will transmit your voice and video quality clearly.
Tips for a successful defence
It is recommended that the following information is reviewed to avoid any problems that could occur during the defence.
Prior to the defence
Install the Zoom Workplace Desktop App atDownload Center for Zoom Apps and Plugins | Zoom if appropriate.
Online attendees should use a headset with a built-in microphone to ensure clear audio and minimized background noise.
The candidate and online attendees should attend their scheduled test video conference session, especially if they are unfamiliar with Webex.
The candidate should circulate their presentation to committee members and other attendees prior to the defence (PDF format preferred)
Reboot and close any applications on your device that will not be needed for the defence a few hours prior to entering the meeting.
If permitted, the candidate is able to forward the defence meeting invitation to family and friends. Please do not share any meeting link information on social media or any public platform. Approval to forward the invitation must be granted by the Chair.
The candidate and committee members are advised to join the meeting in a well-lit (backlighting can make it difficult to see) and quiet place.
At the defence
The candidate and online attendees should join the meeting at 15-20 minutes early to allow time to address any technical issues.
If issues arise during the defence, email hlthcomputing@uwaterloo.ca and include the meeting link and on-campus location
Remote attendees are advised to mute their mics when they are not speaking.
The candidate and online attendees should mute their notifications as described in Quickly muting notifications while in a video conference.
The candidate will share their screen for online attendees to see their presentation (if applicable). After the presentation, the candidate should stop screen sharing.
Remote committee members are encouraged to keep their video camera on (bandwidth permitting). Other online attendees must have their cameras turned off during the defence unless instructed otherwise by the Chair.
All non-committee members (guests) must leave the online meeting after the committee finishes their rounds of questions.
If the defence is entirely online, the Supervisor or Host will move the candidate to the Waiting Room (Zoom) from the participant list during the committee deliberation. When the committee is ready to announce their decision, the Supervisor will use the participant list to re-admit the candidate back into the meeting. For Teams, the candidate must be removed from the meeting and asked to re-join. To do this, first restrict who can bypass the lobby under the Meeting options (set to Only organizers and co-organizers). With this set, when the candidate rejoins after being removed, they will appear at the top of the participants list as in the lobby and must be admitted to the meeting. The lobby settings can be made by the host when creating the meeting or after the meeting has started.
For detailed instructions, see the "During the Meeting" section of the Faculty of Environment's pages for Self-host a defence on Webex or Self-host a defence on Zoom.
Additional Resources
Self-host a remote defence (Faculty of Environment)
For more tips, see Best Practices (not just for Webex)
Zoom Knowledgebase - IST
WebEx Knowledgebase - IST
https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us
If you have any questions or concerns regarding remote defences after reading the information on this page, please contact us.